Which method is superior for choosing the best movie: single transferable vote to plurality, or score voting? Really, last post didn't give enough data. So first: more data. A note though; I moved foreign films into the year of their U.S. release (since that's what determines eligibility for Best Picture). Films that appear in both columns are in bold.
Year |
Academy |
IMDB |
2009 |
not yet determined
|
partial result
- Up
- Star Trek
- The Hangover
|
2008 |
Slumdog Millionaire
- The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
- Frost/Nixon
- Milk
- The Reader
|
- The Dark Knight
- WALL·E
- Slumdog Millionaire
- Gran Torino
- The Wrestler
- Lat den ratte komma in (Let the Right One In)
- The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
- Vals Im Bashir (Waltz with Bashir)
- Ip Man
|
2007 |
No Country for Old Men
- Atonement
- Juno
- Michael Clayton
- There Will Be Blood
|
- No Country for Old Men
- There Will Be Blood
- Into the Wild
- The Bourne Ultimatum
- Ratatouille
- Le scaphandre et le papillon
|
2006 |
The Departed
- Babel
- Letters from Iwo Jima
- Little Miss Sunshine
- The Queen
|
- Das Leben der Anderen (The Lives of Others)
- The Departed
- El Laberinto del Fauno (Pan's Labrinth)
- The Prestige
- Children of Men
- Letters from Iwo Jima
|
2005 |
Crash
- Brokeback Mountain
- Capote
- Good Night, and Good Luck
- Munich
|
- Der Untergang (Downfall)
- Sin City
- Batman Begins
- V for Vendetta
|
2004 |
Million Dollar Baby
- The Aviator
- Finding Neverland
- Ray
- Sideways
|
- Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
- Hotel Rwanda
- Million Dollar Baby
- Tasogara Seibei (The Twilight Samurai)
- The Incredibles
|
2003 |
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
- Lost in Translation
- Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World
- Mystic River
- Seabiscuit
|
- The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
- Oldboy
- Kill Bill: Vol. 1
- Finding Nemo
|
2002 |
Chicago
- Gangs of New York
- The Hours
- The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers
- The Pianist
|
- Cidade de Deus (City of God)
- The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers
- The Pianist
- Sen to Chihiro no Kamikakushi (Spirited Away)
|
2001 |
A Beautiful Mind
- Gosford Park
- In the Bedroom
- The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
- Moulin Rouge!
|
- The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
- Le fabuleux destin d'Amelie Poulain (Amelie)
- Donnie Darko
- Amores Perros (Love's a Bitch)
- Dil Chahta Hai (Do Your Thing)
|
2000 |
Gladiator
- Chocolat
- Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
- Erin Brockovich
- Traffic
|
- Memento
- Requiem for a Dream
- Gladiator
- Snatch
|
So, take some time, look at, and see if it tells you anything. (Note: there are additional categories for "Best Animated Feature" and "Best Foreign Feature", which might explain some of that disparity. But there isn't a "Best Adapted Comic Book Feature".)
Our lone commentary from the last post mentioned that they were upset that Shawshank Redemption didn't win best picture in 1994; you'll be happy to know then that, according to IMDB, it's the greatest movie of all time.
Now, if you like IMDB's results, please ask yourself: if it works so well for movies, why wouldn't it work for elections? If the best method for picking a winner out of dozens and dozens of choices is score voting, why wouldn't it work for picking between two; or, do we only get to decide between two because we don't use a better system to decide?
No comments:
Post a Comment